The "Ugly Ad" Manifesto

Your Designer is a Saboteur: Why Ugly Ads Make Millions

Your Creative Director wants to win a Cannes Lion. You want to buy a second home. These goals are mutually exclusive.

If your marketing team is currently arguing about "kerning," "white space," or the emotional resonance of a specific shade of blue, fire them. They are not building a business; they are scrapbooking with your money.

I see it every day. A brand spends $50,000 on a "Hero Video." They hire a director who wears a beanie in August. They rent a RED camera that costs more than a Honda Civic. They get a craft services table with gluten-free muffins.

They produce a cinematic masterpiece that looks like a perfume commercial where a celebrity whispers at a horse.

They launch it.

And it gets crushed by a shaky vertical video of a 22-year-old in a messy bedroom screaming about how your product saved his life.

Welcome to the era of Ad Ugly.

The "Polished" Penalty

Here is the psychology of the internet in 2025: High production value = A Lie.

When a user sees perfect lighting, perfect skin, and a scripted voiceover, their brain screams: "ADVERTISEMENT! SHIELD UP! IGNORE!"

Glossy ads smell like a corporation. They smell like a committee. They smell like a lawyer approved the script.

Ugly ads smell like the truth.

When the lighting is bad, the camera is shaking, and the audio echoes a little bit, the brain thinks: "This is real content. This is a real person. I can trust this."

You are spending thousands of dollars to look "professional," and all you are doing is signaling to the customer that you are trying to reach into their wallet.

The "Gucci" Exception (and Why We Test)

Now, put your pitchforks down. I am not saying all polished ads are trash. I am not a zealot; I am a capitalist. I follow the money.

If you are selling a $200,000 luxury car or a handbag that costs more than my first apartment, sure. You need the gloss. You are selling a fantasy, not a utility.

But you are probably not Gucci. You are selling a solution to back pain, a SaaS tool, or a subscription box for aggressive chewers.

This is why Creative Testing is not optional. It is the law.

We don't guess. We don't sit in a conference room and vote on which video gives us the "best vibes."

We throw them into the Thunderdome.

We run the $50k "Cinematic Masterpiece" against the $0 "Ugly iPhone Video" and we let them fight to the death.

Spoiler Alert: 9 times out of 10, the ugly video beats the pretty video to death with a folding chair. The other 1 time? Sure, the polished ad wins. But you won't know until you test it. Assuming "pretty is better" is the fastest way to light your budget on fire.

Creative Efficiency: The $0 vs. $50k Battle

Let’s talk math. Let’s talk Creative Efficiency.

• Option A (The Agency Route): $50,000 budget. 6 weeks production time. 3 rounds of revisions because the CEO didn't like the font. Result: 1 video.

• Option B (The Ugly Route): $0 budget. You hand an iPhone 15 to your most unhinged employee or a creator. You shoot 50 variations in one afternoon. Result: 50 videos.

If the $50k video flops, you are out $50k and you have nothing to show for it except a heavy file on a hard drive and a depressed marketing manager.

If the "Ugly" video flops, you delete it and post the next one. You lost 15 minutes.

The "Ugly" strategy allows you to test at the speed of light. The "Pretty" strategy moves at the speed of a government bureaucracy.

Fighting Creative Fatigue

The internet eats content. It chews it up and spits it out.

If you rely on high-production assets, you will hit Creative Fatigue in week two. You cannot produce "cinema" fast enough to feed the beast.

Ugly ads are sustainable. You can make them in your car. You can make them while walking your dog. You can make them on the toilet (please don't, but you could).

Perfect is the enemy of profit.

How to Make a "Good" Ugly Ad

I am not telling you to make trash. I am telling you to make Lo-Fi High-Performance assets.

1. The "Facetime" Aesthetic: Hold the phone close. Look at the lens, not yourself. Talk fast. Act like you just discovered a secret and you have to tell your best friend immediately.

2. The "Hostage Video" Lighting: Natural light is better than studio light. Studio light looks fake. Window light looks like real life.

3. The "Notes App" Screenshot: Some of the highest converting ads in history are just a screenshot of the Apple Notes app with a good offer, set to music. It cost $0 to make and generated 7-figures. Your designer probably vomits when they see it. Good. Their vomit is a leading indicator of your profit.

The Verdict

Stop trying to be HBO. You are not making Game of Thrones. You are selling supplements, or software, or socks.

Your brand guidelines are a vanity project. Nobody cares if the logo has enough "clear space." They care if the product works.

Embrace the ugly. Embrace the chaos. Test everything.

Fire the "visionary." Hire a savage with a smartphone.

👉 [BOOK YOUR STRATEGY SESSION] 👈